Should It Stay or Should It Go? 7 Questions to Declutter with Confidence

By

Ever held an old sweater and thought, Maybe I’ll wear it next winter? Or kept a kitchen gadget because one day you might make homemade pasta? Yep, me too. Decluttering isn’t just about tidying up—it’s a full-on emotional battleground. But if you’ve ever wanted a way to make decisions easier, a few strategic questions can be your best weapon against clutter creep.

Instead of agonizing over every item, these five questions will help you figure out what truly deserves a spot in your home (and what’s just taking up space).

1. Do I Use This Regularly, or Am I Just Keeping It "Just in Case"?

Be honest—when was the last time you used it? If it's been months (or years), chances are you don’t actually need it. "Just in case" is one of the sneakiest excuses for hanging onto clutter.

  • That extra set of measuring cups?
  • The stack of magazines you swear you'll read someday?
  • The fondue pot from your wedding registry (that’s never seen melted cheese)?

I’ve noticed that the more I tell myself I’ll "use it eventually," the more likely it is to collect dust. And let’s be real—if eventually hasn’t arrived yet, it probably never will.

What to Do Instead:

If the item is something you genuinely might need in rare situations (like a first aid kit), keep it. Otherwise, let it go. You can always borrow, rent, or repurchase in the unlikely event you actually need it.

2. Would I Buy This Again Today?

Imagine you're standing in a store right now. The item is on the shelf, full price. Would you eagerly put it in your cart, or would you hesitate?

So many of us keep things out of guilt—because we spent money on them, or because they were gifts. But if you wouldn’t buy it again today, that’s a sign you’re keeping it for the wrong reasons.

  • Clothes that don’t fit quite right but were expensive?
  • Books you feel obligated to read but never actually want to pick up?
  • That fancy skincare product that smelled weird but cost too much to toss?

It seems like the more we try to justify keeping something, the less we actually need it. Let go of the guilt. You’ve already spent the money—keeping the item won’t bring it back.

3. Does This Fit My Current Lifestyle (Not My Fantasy One)?

Ah, the aspirational clutter trap. This is the stuff we keep because we wish we were the type of person who used it.

  • The art supplies for a creative hobby you never actually started
  • The workout gear for a fitness routine you keep putting off
  • The stack of cookbooks for elaborate meals you never make

I used to have an entire cabinet of "healthy eating" gadgets—spiralizers, juicers, meal prep containers. But here’s the thing: I don’t actually enjoy meal prepping. I kept them because I wanted to be the person who did.

What to Do Instead:

Ask yourself, Am I keeping this for my real life, or my idealized version of me? If it’s the latter, it’s okay to admit that and let it go.

4. Would I Actively Choose This Again Today?

It’s one thing to own something because you bought it years ago. It’s another thing to keep it because, given the choice right now, you would still pick it.

This is a gut-check question. If you were standing in a store today, would you willingly buy this again? No discounts, no sunk-cost guilt—just pure, intentional choice.

  • If the answer is yes, great!
  • If the answer is no, then why is it still in your space?

I’ve noticed that the things I struggle to let go of are often relics of a past version of myself—books I thought I’d read, hobbies I swore I’d take up, clothes that suited an identity I don’t really resonate with anymore. Holding onto them doesn’t change the fact that I’ve moved on.

5. Does Keeping This Serve My Present or Just Preserve My Past?

Some things carry history. And history has weight.

There’s a difference between honoring your past and being weighed down by it. A few meaningful keepsakes? Absolutely. A closet full of old jeans you haven’t worn since flip phones were cool? Maybe not.

A good way to test this: If you packed up and moved tomorrow, would you bring it? If not, it might be more of a sentimental placeholder than a truly valued possession.

  • Keepsakes should enhance your space, not clutter it.
  • If the memory is important, consider a digital archive or a single curated memory box.
  • Ask yourself: Am I keeping this because I love it—or because I feel guilty about letting it go?

It seems like we underestimate how much our environment affects our mindset. A space full of "what was" can make it harder to fully embrace "what is."

6. Does This Support the Life I Actually Live?

Aspirational clutter is real. It’s the fancy kitchen gadgets for meals you never cook, the craft supplies for projects you never start, the workout gear for the fitness routine that exists only in theory.

The question is simple: Does this item fit into your actual, day-to-day life? Not the version of yourself you sometimes wish you were, but the real, busy, imperfect, wonderful version of you.

  • If it’s useful and aligns with your lifestyle, keep it.
  • If it’s a "maybe someday" item, ask yourself how long it’s been a "maybe."
  • If it makes you feel guilty every time you see it, consider that a red flag.

I’ve had to accept that I’m just not the kind of person who makes homemade pasta. And that’s okay. But keeping a pasta maker I’ve never used? That’s just unnecessary pressure disguised as an appliance.

7. If This Disappeared Tomorrow, Would I Even Notice?

Sometimes, the best way to know if you truly need something is to imagine it gone.

Would you miss it? Would it inconvenience you in any real way? Or would you suddenly feel... relieved?

This is a great trick for borderline items—the ones that aren’t quite useless but aren’t exactly essential either. If their absence wouldn’t make a dent in your life, their presence probably isn’t adding much value.

  • Try boxing up "maybe" items and revisiting them in a month.
  • If you forget about them completely, that’s a clear answer.
  • If you find yourself missing something, you can always reclaim it.

Most of the time, I forget about the "maybe" items entirely, and that tells me everything I need to know.

Ready to Clear the Clutter for Good?

Decluttering isn’t just about getting rid of stuff—it’s about creating a space that actually works for you. When your home feels lighter, so does your mind. And the best part? You don’t have to go full minimalist to see the benefits.

If you’re ready to dig deeper, there’s so much more to explore—practical strategies, mindset shifts, and real-life tips that make decluttering doable. Start small, stay flexible, and find what feels right for you. Because a clutter-free life isn’t about perfection—it’s about breathing room.

Want more decluttering insights? Stick around. There’s plenty to uncover.