The “One-Year Rule” for Decluttering: Smart Strategy or Outdated Advice?

By

You know the rule: If you haven’t used it in a year, toss it. It’s one of the most famous decluttering mantras, supposedly cutting through decision fatigue like a hot knife through an overstuffed junk drawer. But does it really work for everyone, or is it a one-size-fits-none approach?

I've noticed that rigid decluttering rules often lead to two reactions: relief (“Finally, a clear decision-making system!”) or sheer panic (“But what if I might need it next month?”). The One-Year Rule sits firmly in this polarizing space—helpful for some, unrealistic for others.

Let’s dig into the logic behind it, the problems it creates, and whether there’s a better way to decide what stays and what goes.

Why the One-Year Rule Makes Sense (In Theory)

At its core, this rule is all about cutting the emotional clutter. Instead of agonizing over each item, you apply a simple test:

  • Haven’t worn it in a year? Donate it.
  • Didn’t use that kitchen gadget? Time to let it go.
  • Books still unread after 12 months? Maybe they weren’t that compelling after all.

For those who struggle with indecision, this rule offers a straightforward, almost mechanical way to declutter—especially in categories where emotional attachment isn’t a big factor. Seasonal items aside (because yes, you still need that winter coat even if last year’s winter was oddly warm), it can highlight what’s genuinely useful versus what’s just taking up space.

The Big Problem: Life Doesn’t Always Fit in a 12-Month Window

Now, let’s talk about real life. The One-Year Rule assumes we live in a perfectly predictable cycle where every item’s usefulness resets annually. But that’s not how things work.

Here’s where it gets tricky:

  • Specialty items – You might not reach for your camping gear every year, but when you do need it, you really need it.
  • Aspirational items – That sewing machine you haven’t touched? Maybe last year wasn’t the right time, but what about next year?
  • Rotating interests – Hobbies ebb and flow. Just because you didn’t paint in 2023 doesn’t mean 2024 won’t be your watercolor renaissance.

I’ve found that keeping things I aspire to use is a bit of a gamble, but one I’m sometimes willing to take. The key is knowing when something is genuinely part of your evolving interests versus just guilt sitting on a shelf.

Why “One Year” Might Be the Wrong Timeframe

Twelve months is an arbitrary number. Why not six months? Or two years? The reality is, the best decluttering timeframe depends on the category of stuff and your lifestyle.

Consider these adjustments:

  • Clothing: Instead of the One-Year Rule, try the "Seasonal Wear Test." If you didn’t wear it last winter and don’t reach for it this winter, it’s probably time to let it go.
  • Books & Hobbies: Use the "Excitement Check." If you see it and feel zero excitement about using it in the future, it’s just clutter in disguise.
  • Kitchenware: Apply the "Actual Utility Test." Did it make cooking easier or more enjoyable? No? Then it’s just taking up valuable counter space.

I once held onto a pasta maker for three years thinking I’d finally become the homemade pasta queen I envisioned. Reality check: I used it once. Turns out, I love eating pasta, but making it? Not so much.

What to Do Instead of the One-Year Rule

If the One-Year Rule feels too restrictive, try a more flexible, question-based approach to decluttering:

  • Do I genuinely use this, or do I just feel guilty about getting rid of it?
  • If I didn’t own this already, would I buy it again today?
  • Does keeping this add value to my space and lifestyle?

By shifting the focus from an arbitrary timeline to a purpose-driven decision-making process, you create a decluttering system that actually works for you.

When Sentimental Value Gets in the Way

One of the biggest struggles with decluttering isn’t deciding what’s useful—it’s figuring out what to do with sentimental stuff. The One-Year Rule doesn’t account for the emotional weight of certain items, which is why so many people get stuck when it comes to things like old letters, souvenirs, or that sweater your grandma knitted (even though it’s three sizes too big and made of the scratchiest wool imaginable).

Here’s where I think the One-Year Rule completely falls apart: sentimental value doesn’t expire in a neat 12-month cycle. Some things are meaningful even if you haven’t touched them in years. But keeping every sentimental object “just in case” turns your home into a museum of past emotions.

Instead of a rigid rule, I like the “Curated Memories” approach:

  • Keep only what truly sparks a feeling when you see it, not just because you feel guilty tossing it.
  • Store sentimental keepsakes in a dedicated space—once that box is full, it’s time to reassess.
  • Repurpose meaningful items instead of letting them collect dust (old T-shirts into a quilt, letters into a scrapbook, etc.).

I once found a whole box of concert tickets, birthday cards, and random notes from my teenage years. It was fun to flip through, but most of it didn’t need to be kept. I took pictures of the ones that mattered, kept a few favorites, and let the rest go. And you know what? I don’t miss them.

Decluttering by Lifestyle, Not Arbitrary Rules

Rather than forcing yourself into a time-based rule that may not fit your life, it helps to declutter based on your actual lifestyle. Ask yourself:

  • Is this item supporting the life I live now, or the life I thought I’d have?
  • Does this fit the space I have, or am I cramming my space around it?
  • Am I holding onto this because of guilt, fear, or obligation?

One of the biggest shifts I made in my own decluttering process was realizing that keeping something “just in case” was often a sign that I didn’t trust myself to make good decisions. If I really needed something again, I could borrow, rent, or replace it. More often than not, I never missed the things I let go of.

A More Flexible Decluttering Approach

If the One-Year Rule works for you, great! But if you’re like me and prefer a little more flexibility, consider alternative methods that don’t rely on an arbitrary deadline.

Here are some tried-and-true approaches:

  • The Box Test: Put questionable items in a box, seal it, and set a reminder for 3-6 months later. If you don’t miss anything inside, donate it—no second guessing.
  • The 20/20 Rule (From The Minimalists): If you can replace an item for less than $20 in under 20 minutes, let it go. This works well for “just in case” clutter.
  • The “Does This Fit Me Today?” Test: If something no longer aligns with who you are now, it’s not worth keeping for a version of you that no longer exists.

I’ve found that decluttering isn’t about how long you’ve had something—it’s about how much space (physically and mentally) you’re willing to give it. The best method is the one that helps you live with less stress, not more rules.

Keep Going—Decluttering Gets Easier

Decluttering isn’t about getting rid of everything—it’s about making space for what matters. If the one-year rule works for you, great! If not, that’s okay, too. The goal is to find an approach that feels right for your home and lifestyle. Start small, trust your instincts, and remember: progress is better than perfection.

Want more tips, mindset shifts, and realistic strategies to make decluttering feel less stressful? There’s so much more to explore! Keep learning, keep experimenting, and most importantly—keep creating a home that actually works for you. Because that’s what truly matters.